• Login
    • Join
  • Subscribe Free
    • Magazine
    • eNewsletter
    Checkout
    • Magazine
    • News
    • Exclusives
    • Applications
    • Technology
    • Market
    • Other
    • Top 40
    • Buyers Guide
    • Hygiene Directory
    • More
  • Magazine
  • News
  • Exclusives
  • Applications
  • Technology
  • Market
  • Other
  • Top 40
  • Buyers Guide
  • Hygiene Directory
  • Current / Back Issues
    Features
    Editorial
    Columns
    Digital Edition
    eNewsletter Archive
    Editorial Guidelines
    Subscribe Now
    Advertise Now
    Top Features
    Four Trends Shaping the Future of Nonwoven Wipe Demand

    Regulations Round Up

    It Takes a Village to Make a Wet Wipe

    Wipes and the Modern World

    2018 COMPANY CAPABILITIES
    Company Cameo
    Financial News
    Machinery Equipment
    New Products
    Nonwovens News
    Patent Review
    People in the News
    Supplier News
    Top News
    Live From Shows
    Top News
    Bostik's Brilliance Receives Honor

    INDA Announces WOW Award Finalists

    P&G Sets New Environmental Sustainability Goals

    Drylock Expands European Production

    Artist Uses Evolon for Painting Large-Format Works
    Absorbent Core
    Adult Incontinence
    Antimicrobials
    Apparel
    Automotive and Transportation
    Chemicals / Adhesives
    Construction
    Contract Services
    Diaper, Baby
    Electronics
    Feminine Hygiene
    Fibers
    Filtration
    Flame Retardance
    Geotextile / Agrotextile
    Home Products
    Hygiene Film/Components
    Industrial / Institutional
    Inspection / Quality Control
    Machinery and Equipment
    Medical
    Wipes

    Bostik's Brilliance Receives Honor

    Drylock Technologies Invests in Europe

    INDA Announces WOW Award Finalists

    Drylock Expands European Production

    Four Trends Shaping the Future of Nonwoven Wipe Demand
    Air Through Bonding
    Airlaid
    Carded/Carding
    Chemical Bonded
    Composite
    Meltblown
    Needlepunch
    Nanotechnology
    Spunbond
    Spunlace
    Thermal Bonded
    Wetlaid

    Phantom Veil Offers Molded Composites for Home and Building Structures

    Moldow, Dan-Web Install Airlaid Line in U.S.

    Freudenberg Far Eastern Spunweb Expands in Taiwan

    TFP's Optiveil Used in Hockey Sticks

    U.S. Cotton Adds Spunlace Manufacturing
    China
    Eastern Europe/Russia
    India
    Middle East/North Africa
    North America
    Pacific Rim
    South/Central America
    Turkey
    Western Europe

    Drylock Technologies Invests in Europe

    INDA Announces WOW Award Finalists

    Drylock Expands European Production

    Albaad Expands U.S. Operations

    Unicharm: First Asia, Then The World
    Associations
    Contracts / Awards
    Education
    Facilities / Capacity
    Green / Sustainability
    Legal / Regulatory
    Market Data
    Mergers and Acquisitions
    Product Improvement / Innovation
    R&D/Basic Research
    Shows / Events

    INDA Announces WOW Award Finalists

    P&G Sets New Environmental Sustainability Goals

    Drylock Expands European Production

    Albaad Expands U.S. Operations

    Guilt-Free Diapers
    Chart
    Companies
    All Companies
    Categories
    Company Profiles
    Add New Company
    International Buyers Guide Companies
    Don & Low Ltd. Nonwovens
    Brands
    Brand Owners
    • Magazine
      • Current / Back Issues
      • Features
      • Editorial
      • Columns
      • Digital Edition
      • eNewsletter Archive
      • Editorial Guidelines
      • Subscribe Now
      • Advertise Now
    • Breaking News
    • Buyers Guide
      • All Companies
      • Categories
      • Company Profiles
      • Add Your Company
    • Applications
      • Absorbent Core
      • Adult Incontinence
      • Antimicrobials
      • Apparel
      • Automotive and Transportation
      • Chemicals / Adhesives
      • Construction
      • Contract Services
      • Diaper, Baby
      • Electronics
      • Feminine Hygiene
      • Fibers
      • Filtration
      • Flame Retardance
      • Geotextile / Agrotextile
      • Home Products
      • Hygiene Film/Components
      • Industrial / Institutional
      • Inspection / Quality Control
      • Machinery and Equipment
      • Medical
      • Wipes
    • Technology
      • Air Through Bonding
      • Airlaid
      • Carded/Carding
      • Chemical Bonded
      • Composite
      • Meltblown
      • Needlepunch
      • Nanotechnology
      • Spunbond
      • Spunlace
      • Thermal Bonded
      • Wetlaid
    • Market
      • China
      • Eastern Europe/Russia
      • India
      • Middle East/North Africa
      • North America
      • Pacific Rim
      • South/Central America
      • Turkey
      • Western Europe
    • Other
      • Associations
      • Contracts / Awards
      • Education
      • Facilities / Capacity
      • Green / Sustainability
      • Legal / Regulatory
      • Market Data
      • Mergers and Acquisitions
      • Product Improvement / Innovation
      • R&D/Basic Research
      • Shows / Events
    • Top 40 Companies
      • Chart
      • Companies
    • Online Exclusives
    • Hygiene Directory
      • Brands
      • Brand Owners
    • Slideshows
    • Experts Opinions
    • Videos
    • Podcasts
    • Infographics
    • Whitepapers
    • Jobs
    • Events
      • Industry Events
      • Live From Show Events
      • Webinars
      • Live From Asian Connections
    • Resources
      • Suppliers Gallery
      • Literature Showcase
      • Web Showcase
      • Home Page Showcase
    • About Us
      • About Us
      • Contact Us
      • Advertise With Us
      • Privacy Policy
      • Terms of Use
    Features

    Flushability: The Fight Continues

    As the wastewater industry releases its own version of standards, wipes manufacturers continue to focus on education to keep

    Related CONTENT
    • Jacob Holm
    • INDA Releases North American Capacity Figures
    • EDANA Releases Preliminary 2016 Annual Statistics
    • INDA Elects Six to Board
    • INDA To Co-Sponsor Asian Nonwovens Symposium
    Karen Bitz-McIntyre, Editor09.18.17
    The wipes industry continues to wage its battle in defense of flushable wipes. More than a decade after industry stakeholders began formally addressing negative attention surrounding wipes that are designed to be flushed, it continues to grapple with things like false claims and negative press saying that flushable wipes have caused millions of dollars in damage to sewer systems around the world.

    “The battle is being waged on four fronts—legislation, regulation, litigation and publicity,” says INDA president Dave Rousse. “We have seen some wins in all of these areas but we continue to face challenges.”

    The wipes industry continues to make strides fighting legislative battles. The Federal Trade Commission has closed two inquiries related to the advertising of flushable wipes without finding or alleging that any product currently on the market has violated any performance claim.

    From a regulations standpoint, the wipes industry continues to work with Washington, D.C., in finalizing the language and rulemaking surrounding a bill, passed last year, requiring that wipes pass certain standards before they can be advertised as flushable. At the same time, a similar measure up for debate before the New York City Council seems to have been deprioritized after its sponsors saw an updated Code of Practice on labeling requirements developed by the industry.

    In litigation terms, the flushable wipes industry scored a win in August when a judge in Iowa announced the settlement of a class action lawsuit brought by the City of Perry, IA, in which Perry alleged damages from flushable wipes manufactured by a number of flushable wipes producers. In dropping its lawsuit, Perry admitted that since the inception of its lawsuit, filed in 2015, it had not experienced any clogs or increased maintenance costs attributable to flushable wipes. Perry also admitted that none of its personnel were able to identify any flushable wipes manufactured by select companies in the city’s plumbing or wastewater systems. Notably, Perry agreed to drop its lawsuit without receiving any compensation for any alleged damages.

    In 2016, two of the defendants in the Perry case were able to resolve another flushable wipes class action lawsuit in Florida (Sweeney v. Kimberly-Clark, et al.), where the consumer Plaintiffs also agreed to drop the class action lawsuit without any compensation for alleged damages.

    “The settlement terms of the Perry litigation corroborate what years of testing and field collection studies have shown: that flushable wipes are not causing municipal clogs or increased maintenance,” Rousse says. “To date, despite sensational headlines, there is no evidence from any wastewater agency proving that flushable wipes are causing clogs or maintenance issues.”

    Recent studies point to similar findings. A recent independently conducted collection study in New York City found that more than 98% of the items examined were not labeled or designed to be flushed, including baby wipes, surface cleaning wipes, paper towels, as well as additional trash items. Other collection studies conducted in Maine and California have yielded similar results.

    Amidst these wins, publicity may be the biggest challenge facing flushable wipes as negative articles, falsely blaming the products for clogging sewers, continue to pop up in both local and national media outlets. “We do our Google search every week and the articles keep popping up,” Rousse adds.

    Another challenge appeared this summer with the formation of the International Waste Services Flushability Group (IWSFG), an organization comprised of stakeholders in the wastewater services industry, which is dedicated to the inappropriate disposal of consumer products down the toilet. This organization has proposed its own standards, which are based on three main criteria: The wipes must break into small pieces quickly; not be buoyant and not contain plastic or regenerated cellulose but only contain materials which will readily degrade in a range of natural environments.

    IWSFG released these draft standards on July 24 for public comments until September 1. The final standard will be finalized in late September.

    Rousse calls these standards overkill. “The framework is okay but the pass/fail criteria is way out of line,” he says, adding that the short comments window was particularly unfair to European stakeholders who vacation for much of August.

    “We think they want to use these guidelines as a template for legislation including what is currently underway in Washington, D.C.”

    The formation of this organization is another battle in the war the wastewater industry has waged against flushable wipes. For a while, it looked as if a truce was underway when wastewater executives agreed to team up with INDA and wipes manufacturers in the development of the fourth edition of their flushability guidelines (GD4), but that relationship deteriorated in January 2017 when the wastewater industry exited the conversations. The wastewater industry wrote to INDA saying they were ending these efforts because no meaningful progress had been made since May 2016.

    According to INDA, the wastewater community was insisting on testing requirements that were far more rigorous than necessary.

    “If industry were to accept the pass/fail criteria that wastewater industry stood beside, every flushable wipe on the market today would not pass those standards,” says INDA technical affairs director Jim Loftus. “That implies that every flushable wipe is incompatible with the wastewater systems. This is not something that industry can agree with.”

    However, the collaboration did yield an updated code of practices that will update labeling requirements for non-flushable wipes. “We have successfully developed, in conjunction with the four major wastewater associations, a new code of practice that takes care of the labeling of 93% of wipes sold—the other 7% are the percentage of wipes sold that are designed to be flushable,” Rousse says. “

    "This demonstrates the progress that can be made when both sides take a rational and reasonable approach to change.”

    Without the wastewater industry, the finalization of GD4 has stalled but INDA and its allies continue to work on its passage, “We still believe that today’s material science has advanced significantly since 2013 when the last round of guidelines were developed and we would like to change our protocols to reflect that,” Rousse says. “Right now we are figuring out how.”

    Once the guidelines are finalized, Rousse hopes the industry can move on to focusing on an awareness program that toilets are not trash cans (TANT),” Rousse adds. “Alas the world is not perfect and we are dealing with an angry wastewater sector that is not willing to acknowledge scientific data,” he says.

    He adds the main problem between the nonwovens industry and wastewater agencies was failure to come to an agreement on the definition of the problem. For nonwovens, the problem is the improper flushing of non-flushable materials—like baby wipes, feminine hygiene products and non-flushable paper—whereas the wastewater groups see the improper flushing of incompatible flushable wipes as well as consumer confusion caused by the very existence of flushable products as the problem.

    “The wastewater industry is still angry about the guidelines,” he says. “They say they had no input in them when in fact distinguished wastewater leaders reviewed GD1 and GD2 and made suggestions for improvements which led to GD3.”

    For now, the industry remains stuck at GD3, which Rousse describes as scientifically sound. “There is no evidence that a GD3 compliant wipe has caused damage, but GD3 no longer represents the minimum performance properties of today’s flushable wipes. We can go beyond GD3, but we have not updated the guidelines to reflect the advancements our industry has made in material science.”

    Hot Topics
    INDA’s flushability task force continues to operate through multiple committees dedicated fighting litigation, legislation and the almost daily media assault that is blaming flushable wipes for sewage problems throughout the U.S. and the world when in fact the role of flushable wipes in sewage clogs is decreasing (down from 7% to 2% since 2010 according to analyses) even though sales volumes of these materials are increasing. 

    “This does potentially show a trend, the number of flushable wipes has gone up and baby wipes stayed the same yet you see more baby wipes and less flushable wipes (in clogs)…so what is the problem,” Loftus says.

    Central to INDA’s efforts will be consumer education, to help reduce the number of non-flushable items—like baby wipes—that are going down the toilet. The updated code of practices includes new labeling requirements that not only feature the do not flush logo more prominently on the outer packaging of the wipe, but also requires the same logo be used at the point of use. Also, no baby wipe—regardless of its ability to disperse—can be marketed and labeled as being flushable to hopefully reduce consumer confusion about what can go in the toilet.

    In fact, INDA admits the improper flushing of baby wipes is a growing problem. A recent analysis of clogs in the New York City subway showed that 38% of the material was non-flushable baby wipes, up from an analysis taken seven years ago.

    “Too many people are flushing baby wipes and the assault on flushable wipes is not going to fix this problem,” says Richard Palmer, president of Nehemiah Manufacturing and a representative of the flushability communications committee. In fact, limiting the consumer’s supply of flushable materials will only encourage the use—and flushing—of baby wipes.

    To help address this, INDA and its partners have developed the Responsible Flushing Alliance to promote consumer awareness about what should and should not be flushed. “Individual companies should use their marketing resources and their public relations resources to share this information because it is something that we as an industry has done a poor job of doing,” he adds.
    Related Searches
    • Hygiene
    • kimberly-clark
    • european
    • feminine hygiene
    Related Knowledge Center
    • Wipes
    Suggested For You
    WOW 2017 Draws a Crowd WOW 2017 Draws a Crowd
    INDA Spotlights New Products on Filtration 2017 Website INDA Spotlights New Products on Filtration 2017 Website
    Flushable Wipes Class Action Lawsuit Dropped in Iowa Flushable Wipes Class Action Lawsuit Dropped in Iowa
    Kelheim Fibres Kelheim Fibres' Viloft Honored
    INDA Announces Expanded RISE Program INDA Announces Expanded RISE Program
    Flushability: The Fight Continues Flushability: The Fight Continues
    World of Wipes Conference Hailed a Success World of Wipes Conference Hailed a Success
    Flushability is a Hot Topic at WOW Flushability is a Hot Topic at WOW
    INDA Announces New Date for Filtration INDA Announces New Date for Filtration
    Nonwovens—Best in Class Nonwovens—Best in Class
    INDA To Co-Sponsor Asian Nonwovens Symposium INDA To Co-Sponsor Asian Nonwovens Symposium
    INDA Elects Six to Board INDA Elects Six to Board
    EDANA Releases Preliminary 2016 Annual Statistics EDANA Releases Preliminary 2016 Annual Statistics
    INDA Releases North American Capacity Figures INDA Releases North American Capacity Figures
    Jacob Holm Jacob Holm

    Related Features

    • Wipes
      Four Trends Shaping the Future of Nonwoven Wipe Demand

      Four Trends Shaping the Future of Nonwoven Wipe Demand

      Report tracks growth across geographies, new markets.
      Joy Steed, Smithers Pira 04.12.18

    • Wipes
      Regulations Round Up

      Regulations Round Up

      As the wipes industry continues to grow, companies throughout the supply chain need to keep their eyes on how government init
      04.12.18

    • Wipes
      It Takes a Village to Make a Wet Wipe

      It Takes a Village to Make a Wet Wipe

      The power of partnership is crucial throughout the supply chain.
      Leighann Burke, Customer Marketing Manager, Kimberly-Clark Professional Partnership Products 04.12.18


    • Hygiene Film/Components | Spunlace | Wipes
      Spunlace Market Report

      Spunlace Market Report

      Investments, product development and Asia are shaping the global marketplace.
      Tara Olivo, Associate Editor 03.02.18

    • China | Medical | Wipes
      Winner Wins in Hygiene

      Winner Wins in Hygiene

      100% cotton spunlace nonwovens find success in China and Japan.
      03.02.18

    • Wipes
      The Personal Care Wipes Market

      The Personal Care Wipes Market

      Baby wipes dominate, but smaller categories continue to grow.
      Tara Olivo, Associate Editor 02.02.18


    • Diaper, Baby | Wipes
      Innovation is Alive and Well in Private Label

      Innovation is Alive and Well in Private Label

      Today’s private label manufacturers are at the forefront of new technologies in hygiene.
      Tara Olivo, Associate Editor 01.05.18

    • Industrial/Institutional | Wipes
      Consistency, Cleanliness and Performance Give Industrial Wipes an Edge

      Consistency, Cleanliness and Performance Give Industrial Wipes an Edge

      A range of industries rely on nonwoven wipers in their operations.
      Tara Olivo, Associate Editor 10.09.17

    • North America | Shows/Events | Wipes
      WOW 2017 Draws a Crowd

      WOW 2017 Draws a Crowd

      INDA’s 11th World of Wipes Conference hailed a success.
      09.18.17


    • Antimicrobials | Wipes
      Balancing Wipes Performance with Regulatory Requirements for Disinfectants and Sanitizers

      Balancing Wipes Performance with Regulatory Requirements for Disinfectants and Sanitizers

      The hard surface disinfectant (HSD) wipes market continues to grow at a rapid pace of 5-7% per year globally1. Initially the growth was fueled by convenience and time savings, but as the market has begun to mature, innovation is increasingly integral…
      George Gonzalez, Marketing Manager for Hygiene and Preservation, Lonza Inc. 09.18.17

    • Wipes
      Focus On: Regulated Wipes

      Focus On: Regulated Wipes

      Manufacturers achieve FDA, EPA approval to show safety and effectiveness in certain wipes.
      Tara Olivo, Associate Editor 09.18.17

    • Wipes
      Household Wipes: Consumers Choose Convenience

      Household Wipes: Consumers Choose Convenience

      This segment of the wipes market continues to see innovation and growth.
      Tara Olivo, Associate Editor 05.31.17

    • Spunlace | Wetlaid | Wipes
      Perfecting the Spunlace Process

      Perfecting the Spunlace Process

      Evolution of Andritz injector technology and the development of neXjet.
      03.27.17

    • Wipes
      What’s Happening in Wipes Packaging

      What’s Happening in Wipes Packaging

      From canisters to flat packs to tubs, the container is the consumers’ first introduction to the product.
      Susan Stansbury 03.27.17

    • Wipes
      Personal Care  Wipes Market

      Personal Care Wipes Market

      Specialized wipes continue to emerge in this growing segment.
      Tara Olivo, Associate Editor 02.02.17

    Breaking News
    • Moguls South Carolina Gains ISO Certification
    • U.K. Companies Make Plastic Pact
    • Report Studies Industrial Filtration Market
    • Owens Corning Announces Q1 Results
    • Mann+Hummel Reports Growth
    View Breaking News >
    CURRENT ISSUE

    Household and Personal Care Wipes Spring 2018

    • Four Trends Shaping the Future of Nonwoven Wipe Demand
    • Regulations Round Up
    • It Takes a Village to Make a Wet Wipe
    • Wipes and the Modern World
    • View More >


    Copyright © 2018 Rodman Media. All rights reserved. Use of this constitutes acceptance of our privacy policy The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Rodman Media.